Can primary kidney clear cell adenocarcinoma be differentiated from kidney metastasis with computed tomography?
Le Normand, S.; Soyer, P.; Klein, I.; Hervé, J.M.; Scherrer, A.
Progres en Urologie Journal de l'Association Francaise d'Urologie et de la Societe Francaise d'Urologie 7(3): 403-407
1997
ISSN/ISBN: 1166-7087 PMID: 9273067 Document Number: 474638
To determine if CT scan provides morphologic criteria allowing differentiation between primary renal cell cancer of the clear type (PRCCCT) and renal metastasis (RM). Twenty cases of PRCCCT and 20 cases of RM from various origins (excluding lymphomatous origin) were retrospectively analyzed by two independent readers. CT scans were evaluated with respect to tumor size, shape, location and number of tumors, encapsulation, contour sharpness, presence of calcification, and extrarenal involvement by tumor. A tumor size > 3 cm was more frequently seen in PRCCCT than in RM (100% vs 70% respectively, P < .05). Rounded shape was more frequent in PRCCCT than in RM (90% vs 50% respectively, P < .01). Encapsulation was more frequent in PRCCCT than in RM (70% vs 10%, P < .01, respectively). Calcification was depicted only in PRCCCT (35% vs 0%, P < .01). Enlarged perirenal lymph nodes were less frequent in PRCCCT than in RM (20% vs 55% respectively, P < 0.05). Results of our study show that a constellation of morphologic features suggest the diagnosis of PRCCCT rather than that of RM. Our study suggests that calcification is highly specific for the diagnosis of PRCCCT. However, percutaneous biopsy remains indicated to ascertain the diagnosis.