Value of external fixation in proximal tibial fractures
Bonnevialle, P.; Fouque, E.; Cariven, P.; Bertin, R.; Asencio, G.; Mansat, M.
Revue de Chirurgie Orthopedique et Reparatrice de l'Appareil Moteur 83(7): 602-612
1997
ISSN/ISBN: 0035-1040 PMID: 9515128 Document Number: 480631
This study was a retrospective analysis of 39 proximal metaphyseal tibial fractures treated by Orthofix fixator in two trauma departments. There were 28 men and 10 women with a mean age of 49.5 years. 13 pedestrians were stroked by a car and 18 had a traffic accident on a motorcycle. In 27 cases, the fracture was open with following Cauchoix grading: 15 types 2, 6 types 1 and 6 types 3. All fractures were partially or totally included in the proximal epiphyseal square of the AO system. 14 fractures were metaphyseal, 13 diaphyso-metaphyseal and 12 had an articular irradiation. All external fixations were performed using the Orthofix device, with image intensification. A partial weight bearing was allowed for 2.4 months as an average and full weight bearing at mean 3.7 months. 7 skin grafts, 2 micro surgical (latissimus dorsi) and 2 local flaps were necessary. In 3 patients this technique failed. 3 patients had an autologous bone graft at the metaphyseal and 2 at the diaphyseal fracture site. 30 patients healed without other procedure after an average delay of 5.5 months. During the healing and weight bearing time, 6 frontal deformities appeared and 5 flexion contractures were not reoperated. With a minimum follow up of one year (mean 3 years) 22 fractures had no deformity, 8 had a valgus deformity (5 degrees to 10 degrees) and 3 a varus deformity (6 to 17 degrees). For the 25 patients with an isolated proximal tibial fracture, 11 (44%) had an excellent functional result (no pain, full range knee motion, normal daily activity); 12 (48%) had a good result (episodic pain, minimally knee discomfort, flexion limitation). Orthofix fixator appear to be a good solution for comminuted fractures. These fractures have anatomical and epidemiological particularities. AO classification system is not useful; a new one is proposed. External fixator must be placed meticulously after closed fracture reduction.