Conflicting expert opinions from the legal viewpoint
Pelz, F.J.
Zeitschrift für Arztliche Fortbildung 90(7): 636-639
1996
ISSN/ISBN: 0044-2178 PMID: 9064938 Document Number: 467510
Medical lability actions do rarely without expert assessment. The basic rule of free evidence recognition applies for the evaluation of conflicting expert assessments which forces the judge to examine closely. It is reported about formal mistakes of an expert assessment and the appropriate handling of different expert assessments.
Document emailed within 1 workday
Related Documents
Ćwiklińska, M.; Teresiński, G.; Buszewicz, G. 2015: Medico-legal and legal-penal aspects of expert opinions and adjudication in cases of intoxications with intoxicating agents and ethanol-like intoxicants Archiwum Medycyny Sadowej i Kryminologii 65(2): 77-89Takahama, K.; Ishizu, H.; Oshida, S.; Komura, S.; Sagisaka, K.; Tanaka, N.; Tsunenari, S.; Matoba, R. 1994: Recommendations for preventing transmission of infection with biohazard in the practice of legal medicine (2). Equipment and practical applications. The Medico-Legal Society of Japan, Committee on Expert Opinions Nihon Hoigaku Zasshi 48(2): 105-110
Chowaniec, Cław.; Chowaniec, Młgorzata.; Wilk, M. 2017: Giving medico-legal opinions in cases with suspicion of medical mistake. part 2. Expert evidence in cases with suspicion of medical mistake - expectations, possibilities, threats… Wiadomosci Lekarskie 70(4): 771-777
Weber, M. 2014: Decisions at the end of life of children and adolescents pose particular legal problems. Our expert illuminates the legal status. Judges can deny custody in certain cases Pflege Zeitschrift 67(11): 686-688
Schüler-Springorum, H. 1992: Ability to give legal testimony--from the legal viewpoint ZeitschriftfürArztlicheFortbildung 86(15-16): 811
Sjövall, H. 1970: Objectivity or subjectivity in the rendering of expert opinions Münchener Medizinische Wochenschrift 112(16): 725-731
Bielau, B.; Volkmar, K. 1989: Considerations on presenting expert opinions in public health Zeitschrift für die Gesamte Hygiene und ihre Grenzgebiete 35(6): 379-382
Schilling, H.; Starke, W. 1980: Meniscus surgery. Indications and problems for expert opinions Münchener Medizinische Wochenschrift 122(19): 701-703
Flöthner, R.; Hülse, M.; Partsch, C.J. 1971: Results of 204 expert opinions on the problem of hardness of hearing caused by noise Zentralblatt für Arbeitsmedizin und Arbeitsschutz 21(10): 311-314
Weissauer, W. 1995: Legal liability of subordinate physicians, legal liability for management responsibility from the jurisprudence viewpoint Zeitschrift für Arztliche Fortbildung 89(6): 613-620
Haber, C.; Schärli, A. 2021: Defining Spotting in Dance: a Delphi Method Study Evaluating Expert Opinions Frontiers in Psychology 12: 540396
Mizerska, Młgorzata.; Mizerska, K.; Barzdo, M.; Berent, Jław. 2006: Cardiovascular diseases in medico-legal opinions on work disability Archiwum Medycyny Sadowej i Kryminologii 56(2): 91-94
Truszkiewicz, W.; Pałka, J.; Maciejczak, Pł. 2007: Opinions issued by an expert appointed by a court in civil cases from the point of view of the defendant insurance company Archiwum Medycyny Sadowej i Kryminologii 57(1): 104-110
Freyberger, P. 1971: The radix relicta from the viewpoint of he dental expert Zwr 80(6): 243-245
Janzarik, W. 1992: Homicide markers from the viewpoint of the psychiatric expert Der Nervenarzt 63(11): 656-667
Vorster, C.F. 1995: Expert testimony in malpractice from the physician's viewpoint Zeitschrift für Arztliche Fortbildung 89(6): 584-9; Discussion 589-94
Lindner, E.; Nevrla, F. 1975: Paternity from the obstetrical viewpoint - expert testimony Ceskoslovenska Gynekologie 40(10): 699-700
Poczkodi, S.; Márkus, M.; Harangi, R.; Töröcsik, I. 1985: Induced psychosis and the viewpoint of the forensic psychiatry expert Morphologiai Es Igazsagugyi Orvosi Szemle 25(1): 53-57
Spitz, J.; Hahn, K.; Schauwecker, F.; Ahlers, J.; Weigand, H. 1995: Significance of skeletal scintigraphy in traumatology from the viewpoint of expert assessment Rontgenpraxis; Zeitschrift für Radiologische Technik 48(1): 5-13
Vaton, R. 1988: Is the independence of a medico-legal expert threatened? Acta Medicinae Legalis et Socialis 38(3): 179-182