The effect of health programs on breastfeeding and child mortality in Peninsular Malaysia
Anderson, K.H.
Research in Population Economics 5: 87-112
1984
ISSN/ISBN: 0163-7878 PMID: 12266419 Document Number: 407528
Examining household behavior in Peninsular Malaysia, this study attempts to determine if the availability of certain government health programs significantly alters breastfeeding and if these changes in input prices significantly affect mortality rates and fertility decisions. To explain the interrelationships, an economic model of the demand for infant survival and fertility and the derived demand for breastfeeding is developed. Using household and community level data, the demand equations are then estimated and the results discussed in relation to the predictions of the model and the prospect of additional government inputs. The theoretical model predicts that, if income effects are small: a decline in the price of children (hospital distance) will increase fertility, decrease survival and reduce breastfeeding; a decline in the price of health goods inputs (hospital distance and sanitation) will reduce fertility and increase survival; and a decline in the price of contraceptives (family planning distance) will reduce fertility but increase survival and breastfeeding. The empirical results support some of the model's predictions. In communities with modern sanitation, breastfeeding was shorter on average, as predicted, but differences in mortality were not detected and fertility was actually higher. The latter effect can result from an income effect in the price decline that exceeds the cross substitution effect. Distance to a hospital was positively associated with breastfeeding length. This is expected if the effect of distance on the price of children exceeds the effect of distance on the price of survival. Hospital distance had no impact on either survival or fertility. Distance to a family planning clinic had no effect on breastfeeding or fertility but had a slight positive association with mortality. This positive relationship is expected if fertility and survival are substitutes. Parental schooling and race also are important in determining demand. As economic development proceeds and educational attainment increases, breastfeeding and fertility declined and survival increased. The Chinese, the wealthiest racial group, had lower fertility and mortality and breastfed less than Malays or Indians. The empirical results failed to support the prediction of differences in male and female survival. The results suggest some interesting implications. If breastfeeding has been declining in low income countries such as Malaysia as they develop, the culprit may be the economic development process itself, which increases the value of a woman's time and raises family income. The decline in breastfeeding does not necessarily imply a significant increase in infant mortality if good substitutes for breastfeeding exist. In addition, breastfeeding is highly substitutable with many government programs designed to reduce mortality. In designing policies which will bring about a decline in infant mortality rates, both cross substitution and joint production must be considered. Programs that can be most successful in reducing mortality will be the programs that are the least substitutable with breastfeeding.