On the constitutionality of tobacco regulation in Mexico
Madrazo Lajous, A.
Salud Publica de Mexico 50(Suppl): S323-S333
2008
ISSN/ISBN: 0036-3634 PMID: 18604353 Document Number: 616593
As tobacco control legislation gains ground, public debate on the matter has come to be cast in constitutional terms. The present essay aims to provide information so as to participate in the debate in an informed manner. First, it explores the constitutional grounding for tobacco control. Then it analizes, one by one, the key arguments put forth to challenge the constitutionality of tobacco control legislation, reaching the conclusion that none of the challenges holds water.
Document emailed within 1 workday
Related Documents
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Valdés Salgado, R.; Hernández-Avila, M. 2006: Mexico without tobacco Salud Publica de Mexico 48(Suppl 1): S1-S3
Regalado-Pineda, J.; Rodríguez-Ajenjo, C.José. 2008: The role of the National Office for Tobacco Control in Mexico Salud Publica de Mexico 50(Suppl): S355-S365
2002: Perspectives of research-action against tobacco use in Mexico. The Interinstitutional Meeting of Cocoyoc Salud Publica de Mexico 44 Suppl. 1: S194-S202
Ballin, S.D. 2000: FDA and tobacco regulation in the 21st century: where are we headed? Journal of the American Medical Women's Association 55(5): 320-321
Shah, V.; Malek, S.H.; Brown, T.; Moeykens, B. 2010: Reducing tobacco use in tobacco country: North Carolina's success story in lowering tobacco use among youth North Carolina Medical Journal 71(1): 81-82
Nguyen, M.N.; Potvin, L.; Otis, J. 1995: Is municipal regulation of tobacco use applicable to Laval, Quebec? Canadian Journal of Public Health 86(4): 266-268
Richman, B. 2010: On the constitutionality of health care reform North Carolina Medical Journal 71(3): 232-238
Quast, T.; Gonzalez, F. 2017: Sex Work Regulation and Sexually Transmitted Infections in Tijuana, Mexico Health Economics 26(5): 656-670
Balderas Arrieta, I. 1996: Mujeres trabajadoras en el Valle de México - Working women in Mexico Valley - Femmes actives dans la vallée de Mexico Acta Sociologica (Mexico) (16): 209-230
Burke, M. 1992: The constitutionality of the use of the Norplant contraceptive device as a condition of probation Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly 20(1): 207-246
Carlson, J. 2012: Targeting constitutionality. Providers going to court over state CON laws Modern Healthcare 42(37): 18
Devlin, M.M. 1986: Constitutionality of California's Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act and other matters Journal of Medical Practice Management: Mpm 1(4): 272-274
Granollers Mercader, S. 1999: The World Day of Tobacco: "the decision has been made, I reliquish tobacco". The World Health Organization promotes the World Day Without Tobacco on the 31. May since 1998 Revista de Enfermeria 22(5): 346