What is heterosexual coercion? Interpreting narratives from young people in Mexico City
Marston, C.
Sociology of Health and Illness 27(1): 68-91
2005
ISSN/ISBN: 0141-9889 PMID: 15762952 DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-9566.2005.00432.xDocument Number: 262644
Freedom from sexual coercion is frequently cited as essential for good sexual health. Sexual experiences cannot usually be observed directly, and interpretation of interview data is therefore crucial in our understanding of sexual behaviour. This paper explores the ways in which narratives can be used to understand sexual experiences, using coercion as a specific example. The narratives examined are from interviews with young people in low-income areas of Mexico City. This study demonstrates that sexual coercion is impossible to define objectively. In addition, the concept of coercion is focused too much on women, excluding men's negative sexual experiences, and can include events that the 'victims' do not see as coercive. Coercion is a highly subjective and fluid concept, limiting its value as a defining element of sexual health. An alternative way of conceptualising coercive experiences is suggested.
Document emailed within 0-6 h
Related Documents
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Barquera, R.; Martínez-Álvarez, J.C.és.; Hernández-Zaragoza, D.I.íz.; Bravo-Acevedo, A.; Juárez-Nicolás, F.; Arriaga-Perea, A.ín.J.ó; Vega-Martínez, M.ía.D.R.; Ortega-Yáñez, A.; Benítez-Arvizu, G.; Arrieta-Bolaños, E.; Clayton, S.; Juárez-Cortés, E.D.; López-Gil, C.ón.; García-Álvarez, R.; Arrazola-García, M.ía.A.; Martínez-Bezies, V.; Juárez-Barreto, V.; Ramos-de la Cruz, F.D.R.ío.; Macías-Medrano, R.M.ía.; Méndez-Mani, P.; Escutia-González, A.; Montiel-Hernández, G.D.; Immel, A.; Pavón-Vargas, M.ía.d.L.Án.; Salgado-Galicia, N.; Novelo-Garza, B.ár.; Zúñiga, J.ín.; Yunis, E.J.; Bekker-Méndez, C.; Granados, J. 2020: Genetic diversity of HLA system in six populations from Mexico City Metropolitan Area, Mexico: Mexico City North, Mexico City South, Mexico City East, Mexico City West, Mexico City Center and rural Mexico City Human Immunology 81(9): 539-543
Saarikkomäki, E. 2015: Perceptions of Procedural Justice Among Young People: Narratives of Fair Treatment in Young People's Stories of Police and Security Guard Interventions British Journal of Criminology 56(6): 1253-1271
Erulkar, A.S. 2004: The experience of sexual coercion among young people in Kenya International Family Planning Perspectives 30(4): 182-189
Ajuwon, A.J.; Akin-Jimoh, I.; Olley, B.O.; Akintola, O. 2001: Perceptions of sexual coercion: learning from young people in Ibadan, Nigeria Reproductive Health Matters 9(17): 128-136
Sherwin, S. 2016: Performing school nursing: Narratives of providing support to children and young people Community Practitioner: the Journal of the Community Practitioners' and Health Visitors' Association 89(4): 30-34
Winskell, K.; Hill, E.; Obyerodhyambo, O. 2011: Comparing HIV-related symbolic stigma in six African countries: social representations in young people's narratives Social Science and Medicine 73(8): 1257-1265
Winskell, K.; Obyerodhyambo, O.; Stephenson, R. 2011: Making sense of condoms: social representations in young people's HIV-related narratives from six African countries Social Science and Medicine 72(6): 953-961
Wight, D. 1992: Impediments to safer heterosexual sex: a review of research with young people Aids Care 4(1): 11-23
Sowers, M.; Gonzalez Villalpando, C.; Stern, M.P.; Fox, C.; Mitchell, B.D. 1995: Relationships between physical activity, insulin levels and lipids in non-diabetic low income residents of Mexico City: the Mexico City Diabetes Study Archives of Medical Research 26(2): 133-140
Lopez Juarez, A.; Reid, A. 1989: Gente Joven: a community program for Mexico's young people Integration 1989(20): 4-15
Lopez Juarez, A.; Reid, A. 1989: Gente Joven: a community program for Mexico's young people Integration 1989(20): 4-15
Carrasco Sosa, S.; González Camarena, R.; Gaitán González, M.J. 1992: Densitometric validation of nine anthropometric prediction equations of body composition in young native men of Mexico City Archives of Medical Research 23(1): 43-49
Calderón-Narváez, G. 1972: The problem of drug dependence of young people of Mexico. I. General considerations Gaceta Medica de Mexico 103(5): 379-381
Marston, C. 2004: Gendered communication among young people in Mexico: implications for sexual health interventions Social Science and Medicine 59(3): 445-456