Recognition of depressed affect in hospitalized psychiatric patients: staff and patient perceptions
Craig, T.J.; van Natta, P.A.
Diseases of the Nervous System 37(10): 561-566
1976
ISSN/ISBN: 0012-3714 PMID: 971647 Document Number: 103332
A comparison of self-report vs. observer rating of depressed mood in a heterogenous inpatient population revealed wide variations in concordance among diagnostic groups. Patients diagnosed as having Affective Psychosis and ""Other'' illnesses showed the highest correlation between four self-report scales and an observer rating scale. Patients with a diagnosis of depressive Neurosis showed only modest correlation, while Schizophrenics revealed no significant correlation, on these instruments, suggesting inconsistent communication of affect from Schizophrenic patients to observers. In contrast, when self-report scales were intercorrelated, patients in all four diagnostic categories showed highly significant correlations, indicating that they were consistently reporting their affective state on these instruments. The implications of these findings for future research as well as for practical clinical management are discussed.